How do super bowl referees get chosen

He's joined by four others on the crew who have already worked one Super Bowl. The NFL will certainly be hoping that no one is talking about the officials beyond Thomas' history-making come Super Bowl Sunday — if no one is talking about the folks in stripes, that's a good thing for the league.

The other major officiating narrative for the season was the alteration on how holding is called. Holding penalties were greatly reduced this season as officials let more things go, but that would just create even more anger if the officials in the Super Bowl get holding-happy. Below, you'll find more about the officiating crew assigned to the final game of the NFL season along with what each of their roles will be on the field.

The first seven officials listed will be on the field during Super Bowl Wimmer will be in the replay booth, which has been his role in all but two games of his NFL officiating career. Wimmer, Coleman and Thomas have never officiated in a Super Bowl, while five of the on-field officials have been in one prior Super Bowl. The NFL chooses its Super Bowl officials based on a combination of experience along with performance throughout the season.

According to Football Zebras, in order to be considered for the Super Bowl, a referee " must have at least five years of seniority, worked three years at the referee position and worked a playoff game as a referee in the previous postseason.

Thomas becomes the first woman to officiate in a Super Bowl. All dealers were heavily discounting their inventory. The ring was purchased and will escape the scrap metal future to which it was once destined.

The memory of the Super Bowl will live on. Please purchase a subscription to continue reading. Subscribe today and support local community journalism. This includes access to the electronic replica edition of The Pilot. As a print subscriber, you also have unlimited digital access. Connect your account now. Our best deal: Get all the news of Moore County delivered to your home each Wednesday and Sunday — and receive unlimited digital access to thepilot.

Sorry , an error occurred. Get Started. Tier 3 officials do not even get alternate assignments. Super Bowl alternates typically have an on-field playoff assignment earlier in the playoffs, and depending on the number of Tier 1 and 2 officials, some may work as both an alternate and on the field in different rounds.

The Super Bowl has five alternates: a referee, a umpire, a short wing head linesman or line judge , a deep wing side judge or field judge , and a back judge. In the season, no umpires were assigned alternates, except for the Super Bowl, presumably to ensure every game has a backup white hat. It is unclear if that will hold in Alternate officials generally assist the crew on the sideline in various game administration roles. For example, one is assigned as a replay field communicator and another works as the coordinator of the kicking ball supply.

Replay officials and replay assistants are graded separately, but, as long as there are no other disqualifying factors or adverse performance marks, they are generally paired with their regular season referee. The replay booth communicator and the clock operators who work locally during the regular season are assigned from another city, typically one from the other conference.

The chain crew is the same from the regular season. Good informative article.. But the tier level is ridiculous. Both of the dalass games mentioned, allowed dalass to win their division.

Playoff assignment procedure First, to qualify for any postseason assignment, an official may not be in the first season or the first season as referee. Super Bowl The Super Bowl assignment would be selected from the Tier 1 officials, but these minimum qualifications apply: Referee Other positions 5 years of NFL experience 3 years as NFL referee 1 postseason game as a referee in a previous season 5 years of NFL experience Postseason experience of either: 1 career conference championship game 3 playoff games in the previous 5 years Referee Brad Allen and side judges Brad Freeman, Eugene Hall, and Scott Novak are in their first year of Super Bowl eligibility.

Conference Championships The remaining Tier 1 officials are distributed to the Conference Championship round and, if necessary, to the Divisional Playoffs. Pro Bowl The Pro Bowl is assigned to the most senior member at each position not working a playoff game who also has not worked a Pro Bowl.

Multiple sources with knowledge of the grading system made the same claim to Yahoo! Though officials who spoke to Yahoo! Sports say Boger is far from the worst official in the game, they question his assignment to this year's Super Bowl. You see when grades appear, and when grades mysteriously disappear. Any incorrect call or missed call will disappear for no reason at all.

Sports: "There is no merit to the suggestion that Jerome Boger's grades were treated differently from those of any other official. Signora continued: "Every official has the opportunity to have preliminary grades reviewed, and no downgrade is removed unless there is a consensus among the supervisors to do so, and without the approval of the head of the department.

Fourteen of our 18 referees had grades modified in the course of the review process. The larger issue, according to the officials, is a system that many feel is flawed.

Officials are graded after each game by a group of retired referees. Any downgrades or "dings" for mistakes during the game can be appealed by an official, and are then reviewed by supervisors and the league. Mistakes made in games can be altered or erased by the league with no explanation.

Officials are overseen by Ray Anderson, the NFL's vice president of football operations, who has been at his position since Roger Goodell promoted him after becoming commissioner in Requests for an interview with Anderson were declined. Officials told Yahoo!

Sports the mystery of league decisions adds to resentment among their peers. One even said the referees at their annual preseason clinic try to predict who will be chosen for the Super Bowl, even though that assignment is supposed to be based on a season's worth of games. Some guys are Teflon, other guys are Velcro. In explaining the standards for refereeing a Super Bowl, Signora told Yahoo! Sports "the criteria for referees to be eligible for the Super Bowl is three years experience as a referee [and five years total] and playoff experience as a referee.

That criteria has not changed since at least Boger has worked three divisional playoff games as a referee in nine years, the third of those coming earlier this month. He's never worked in a conference championship game or Super Bowl in any capacity. Signora explained that the reason the standard is lower for referees is because they tend to come into the league at different positions and accrue postseason experience at those positions.